Advertisement
Log in or register to post comments
Guest's picture

too bad

Guest
Joines's picture

awful.

Joines
Activity Score 181
Sixth Form
Guest's picture

gross, really gross

Guest
jackmancer2017's picture

Misleading. People will think there's cow meat, or worse, cow blood in that whine.

jackmancer2017
Guest's picture

whats the point of this campaign? what does it sell?

Guest
Billoughsby's picture

Sure it's silly. I think that was the vehicle for the message, a goofy little joke.

The art direction hurts it more than the basic idea, imo.

Billoughsby
Activity Score 5144
Art Director |

That's it.

Guest's picture

malo en verdad, como del 98.

Guest
gon_enelcamino's picture

horrible

gon_enelcamino
Activity Score 838
Underground
Guest's picture

Como sus partidos en la liga?

Guest
Guest's picture

An elegant, simple idea that says Carmen goes with any cut of beef. Now that wasn't so hard, was it, fellow critics?

Guest
Adaddicted's picture

Juan??!

Adaddicted
Activity Score 3435
Art Director |

withalltherespects

Guest's picture

I think comments are just showing envy for a good work. What to do against that? ... nothing....

Guest
Richard Finch's picture

I like it. First thought that came to mind was that Carmen wine will fit perfectly within my meals of beef.
It makes no sense to overanalyze since consumers won't.

Richard Finch
Activity Score 201
Graphic Designer
Guest's picture

very nice, simple and clear.

Guest
shahidali's picture

I was confused as to what the message is. Read the comments and understood that i'm not alone. However, understood the message (if the comments are right). Think a copy might help as mentioned by a guest "Carmen goes with any cut of beef"

shahidali
Activity Score 4069
Dhaka, Bangladesh |

shahid

Anne's picture

I just don't get it.

Anne
Activity Score 508
Art Director
attheadsoftheworld's picture

Beyond cow's milk.

5 pegs if you are simple to accomodate from base of ribs till lower part of neck.

After that u might lose control.

Hello Jack !

"For those who are happy with cow's milk..5P will not ruin your brain."

attheadsoftheworld
Activity Score 2
Under an independent art director to get in....
Roger Keynes's picture

Meh. You must all drink Chardonnay.

I like it. Clink!

Roger Keynes
Activity Score 5498
Copywriter |

The Jobless Writer
Will Think for Salary

Anonymous Author's picture

Red wine, red meat. Simple. Doesn't make it a good ad though.

Anonymous Author
Activity Score 1541

Write a wise saying and your name will live forever – Anonymous.

http://www.anonymousauthor.co.nz
www.twitter.com/@anonauth

Amish's picture

BAAAAAAAAD

Amish
Activity Score 61
Guest's picture

gooooooood !

Guest
Guest's picture

Una idea de esas para olvidar, sin concepto, eterea, de primer año de estudio. Una bofetada a la gente de Ads of the world para filtre de manera más acusiosa a la gente que publica bodrios como ese.

Guest
Guest's picture

...pero para opinar hay que dar la cara, y no ocultarse en un "guest".

Guest
Guest's picture

One of the best wine adds ever.

Guest
AssassinX's picture

English beef cut or American cut or Kazakhstan cut.

Simple and clean, but really not attractive I have to say.

I dont know much about this country and just assume maybe the local people have beef and lamb dishes with strong liquor. So how about showing a dinner table without the liquor on it but this wine? It's an idea of transforming local customs.

AssassinX
Activity Score 1329
aziz mangrio's picture

nice

aziz mangrio
Activity Score 2
Graphic Designer at Karachi/Pakistan
JCSaiKrishna's picture

nice idea, but not really a strong one!

JCSaiKrishna
Activity Score 725
Copywriter at Ogilvy & Mather |

http://twitter.com/JCSaiKrishna
I'm excited to know my mistakes!

wesso85's picture

so gross .

wesso85
Activity Score 4
graphic designer
Guest's picture

It's pretty obvious people, it's saying that it goes with beef - any cut of beef.

You'd have to be pretty damn stupid to think this ad is saying that there's cow blood in the wine!?!

Guest
Featured Content

Latest Collections

Advertisement