Advertisement
Log in to post comments
Vicky's picture

So? What? Weak message.

Vicky
Activity Score 375
Creative Director
Vicky's picture
Vicky
Activity Score 375
Creative Director
refrigerator robot's picture

social smokers will obviously get that.... mainly based on their belief that beer and cigarettes are such good complements

refrigerator robot
Activity Score 10
Other
Vicky's picture

Im a "social smoker", but the ad doesnt persuade me at all of doing or stop doing anything. Its Just, that for me, it needs a stronger copy or maybe the strategy could be better.

Vicky
Activity Score 375
Creative Director
addyhoch10's picture

of course it doesn't persuade you.
as a smoker, you feel offended by anti smoking ads (evident, considering the fact that these ads usually portray smokers as weak, unambitious and sometimes as dumb).
the point about anti smoking ads is to keep people aware of the dangers of smoking and to socially ostracise smoking, especially within the younger generations.

i think it's a good thought.

addyhoch10
Activity Score 2592
Art Director
tjb1970's picture

i have to disagree with the thought that these particular ads somehow ostracise smoking. if anything they make it look cooler—'hey look, they've made cigarettes for people like me who only smoke when they drink.'

you can't get cute with this kind of message and these ads feel kinda cute to me.

tjb1970
Activity Score 492
Creative Director
addyhoch10's picture

no, these particular ads don't really include the aspect of ostracising smoking, i was rather referring to anti-smoking ads in general.

if someone's reading the text on the packages and goes "hey, cool" he will also read the line at the bottom of the page which exposes the "cute" packages as the visualised self-deception, the mentality of playing-down one's own habit/addiction.
naaaarf

addyhoch10
Activity Score 2592
Art Director
Vicky's picture

Antismoking campaigns, mostly, are just political horses for a few people, they really dont give a shit about no one health.

But you are right, i dont like antismoking ads, as a creative because most of them are so lame, and as a smoker.

In fact,at this moment, i could use a good glass of 23 year old Rum and a smoke, so, im gonna hit the bar, right now!

Cheers!!

Vicky
Activity Score 375
Creative Director
addyhoch10's picture

hehe, cheers

addyhoch10
Activity Score 2592
Art Director
ellehcimeo's picture

I like it!

ellehcimeo
Activity Score 3376
Art Director
tjb1970's picture

i think you need to be much more in your face with this kind of message. these fall a little flat. i know that social smoking is still smoking, now convince me that it is equally harmful to my health.

tjb1970
Activity Score 492
Creative Director
x-men's picture

it´s doesn´t persuade me either. they are not convincing.
they tell a truth that has no importance to a smoker.

x-men
Activity Score 340
Creative Director
No fixed abode's picture

Nice insight. Boring execution

No fixed abode
Activity Score 380
Copywriter
raverus's picture

extreme boring, from the extreme, lolz

raverus
Activity Score 1476
Art Director
krshna's picture

its my thought!
i think occassional smokers might give a thought about it.

krshna
Activity Score 6
Copywriter
otto54's picture

First idea.

otto54
Activity Score 381
Art Director |

----------------------------
Advertising pass, pasta remain...

Kin's picture

why spent money targetting at social smokers...if they do their research right...person having 1 or 2 ciggies a day is not considered a smoker...at least that's what my insurance company says...having 1 or 2 burgers will actually do more damage...

Kin
Activity Score 86
Creative Director
Yeminius's picture

I'm identified with this one! :D

and I'll still smoke when I drink... it damages you, as drink does too.

great campaign anyway! nice insights

Yeminius
Activity Score 151
Other
puppiepoppy's picture

EXTREMELY LAME.....

puppiepoppy
Activity Score 1634
Creative Director |

www.michaelwongcc.com

kc_brock's picture

wake me when it's over.

kc_brock
Activity Score 703
Art Director |

rd

Blahg's picture

I think they're dead on. Keep in mind that in Canada, all cigarette packaging HAS to include graphic images of rotting teeth, black lungs and birth defects. Canada has aggressive cigarette packaging and the Department of Health mandatory warning label takes up almost 25% of the packaging.

Canadian smokers are perhaps more swamped than Americans and Europeans with in your face pictures designed to shock them into giving up their habit. It may even be that shock ads have become clutter and some are starting to tune out, especially those with the mindset that its not a big problem and they're not really smokers if they only steal a smoke when they're downing a pint.

Extreme's ad is clever. It's colourful, different and stands out in the marketplace that they're pushing it in, which also happens to include a much higher than normal concentration of Universities and educated young urbanites who happen to also make up a high proportion of casual smokers.

As someone who competes in the same market as Extreme, they are dead on.

Blahg
Activity Score 616
Copywriter
ellehcimeo's picture

Lovely, dead-on summation. Bravo!

ellehcimeo
Activity Score 3376
Art Director
flurl's picture

Are you kidding me? Someone's targeting occasional smokers now? Why? You need full-time smokers to become these people before they're able to quit.

There's nothing wrong with having a cigarette every few weeks after a night of drinking. So many worse things for you.

I'm sorry, it's nothing against the ad, which is alright (safe, but gets the point across) this is a big strategic cock-up though. $.02

flurl
Activity Score 97
Featured Content

Latest Collections

Advertisement