Advertisement
Log in to post comments
jiblp's picture

Oh not again?? Another ad copied from student work??

Explain this to me Ivan please! I saw this a couple of weeks ago. It happened to me with WWF ad, and now to another student that did the same with Wonderbra! Are some agencies copying from students??

here is the link, you will see http://adsoftheworld.com/forum/exhibition/wonderbra_2_0

jiblp
Activity Score 84
Copywriter
creative.jvin's picture

http://sandeepmakam.blogspot.com/2007/03/dreams-lingerie.html

done and released in december 2006. sorry mate. Maybe the Student copied.

creative.jvin
Activity Score 6
Creative Director
chintan ruparel's picture

guys, he has a point...mayb the student copied...check out the link above.

chintan ruparel
Activity Score 1516
Copywriter |

~ old habits die hard, older ones never do ~

copywriter.txt's picture

Maybe the student got a job and now he is the CD/AD at Grey.

copywriter.txt
Activity Score 828
Copywriter
Dick Huges's picture

Seriously, even though they said it did run in December 06. I really think this piece never ran. And I have 99% of chance to be right.

Dick Huges
Activity Score 937
Copywriter
ivan's picture

How does the linked March 7 post proves December 2006???

ivan
Creative Director at Ads of the World
creativemobs's picture

Chori Chori...Chupke Chupke...

It seems the entire team of GREY Worldwide, New Delhi, India is desperate
for awards...

Please please..browse the whole website...before doing the ad...

See this...

http://adsoftheworld.com/forum/exhibition/wonderbra_2_0

Hard luck to the whole team:

Creative Directors: Sandipan Bhattacharyya, Manoj Deb
Art Director: Manoj Deb
Copywriter: Sandipan Bhattacharyya
Photographer: Madhukar Soma
Graphic Artist: Ashish Roy

creativemobs
Activity Score 18
Copywriter
Pouts's picture

Hey c'mon dont steal!!!! that's a student ad from the Exhibition c'mon!!!!

Pouts
Activity Score 693
Art Director
pindaro's picture

and the students is better by far!!!

pindaro
Activity Score 524
Creative Director |

www.pindaro.info

lsadunb's picture

Ok. Everybody knows bras make your breasts bigger. Millions of funny ways of telling this idea were made. How bout another argument?

lsadunb
Activity Score 571
Copywriter
addyhoch10's picture

they not really make them bigger, they make them LOOK bigger and shapely.
big difference.
maybe that's why i don't like the idea.

addyhoch10
Activity Score 2592
Art Director
Twombl's picture

Stop it please!

Twombl
Activity Score 180
Copywriter
Jonny Lonestar's picture

self-righteous. trying-too-hard witty. mind numbingly dull. ( nothing makes a girl want to feel sexy like dishes.)

copied or not. it's another wonderbra ad, not only a tired subject, but also an incredibly easy one. and it does it's little part to help perpetuate the male-centric ad world.

Is this a visual pun about big breasts? or is this seriously supposed to make a woman consider the product? ..... 0/10 ... next.

oh, and shot as sexy as a smokey back-room mob scene.

Jonny Lonestar
Activity Score 282
Art Director
everartz's picture

im scratching my bushy hair scalp while seeing this!.. thinking.. is it worth it using such analogy to tell that my girlfriend's boobs are "similar" to a dish!!! fu*k it man... this is just........absurd!

everartz
Activity Score 7613
Art Director |

| everartz |

Ney Frances's picture

hahahahaha! made my day!

Ney Frances
Activity Score 660
Copywriter |

is there life before death?

chintan ruparel's picture

copied from every angle.. this is so stolen!
shame to you grey new delhi!

chintan ruparel
Activity Score 1516
Copywriter |

~ old habits die hard, older ones never do ~

justpassingby's picture

now which classy bird is honestly going to slap her tits on the table?

And why four people? Dinner for two would have been much better

justpassingby
Activity Score 1368
Other
No fixed abode's picture

Wonderbra I think is an aspirational product. Just because you can show bigger boobs like this, why would you? Where the fark is the benefit? The WIIFM if you will? The more I know of advertising the more I hate it.

No fixed abode
Activity Score 380
Copywriter
djspiralz's picture

anyway, if its a push up bra, then it shouldn't let the girls boobs fall over the table

djspiralz
Activity Score 491
Copywriter
Global Cheese's picture

Global Cheese

Rubbish!

Grey India seems to steal alot of other peoples ideas, then fuck them up. You're right.
I believe it's time to expose them.

Global Cheese
Activity Score 80
Creative Director |

Global Cheese

Rog's picture

Nothing remotely sexy about this idea.

Rog
Activity Score 6080
Copywriter |

>>>> That's not an ad. THIS is an ad.

nuclearshower's picture

There shudnt be any forum to discuss idea, There's thief around here!!!!! this is pathetic!

nuclearshower
Activity Score 233
Art Director
Kay's picture

COINCIDENCE?

Kay
Activity Score 161
Art Director
mikelite's picture

oh who cares if this schmuck steals from a student! let him steal all the crap he wants. IT'S STILL A BORING, TRITE P.O.S.

mikelite
Activity Score 1031
Copywriter |

http://mikelightman.com/blog

addyhoch10's picture

interesting... nobody really knows if this was stolen or not and if it was, by whom, the student or the agency.
anyway, so many are picking on the agency. is it solidarity with a poor student against the big bad agency or just some sort of group dynamics?

totally agree that the idea isn't that good to be worth fighting for.

addyhoch10
Activity Score 2592
Art Director
ruchika's picture

Sandipan Bhattacharyya, Manoj Deb. JWT, India.

Such senior people in advertising and stealing student work??? Fantastic!

ruchika
Activity Score 28
Art Director
chimie's picture

and even the brand does not exist, I think after a google search

chimie
Activity Score 156
Copywriter
creative.jvin's picture

For Info:

Release Date: 30th Dec, 2006
Publication: The Pioneer(English Daily)

creative.jvin
Activity Score 6
Creative Director
amit parekh's picture

dude check student work in adsoftheworld....it hasdone by student...sorry

amit parekh
Activity Score 283
Art Director
creative.jvin's picture

For Info:

Release Date: 30th Dec, 2006
Publication: The Pioneer(English Daily)

creative.jvin
Activity Score 6
Creative Director
fifthbullet's picture

is better to provide a link as the proof than keep on repeating the info.

fifthbullet
Activity Score 186
Art Director |

criticize is way easier than create. use more brain.

mrtalented's picture

looks like Wonderbra wannabe.

mrtalented
Activity Score 2171
Creative Director
rahool's picture

ok.....let me clr...
this is not a stolen idea..i knw the frc bhnd this...
if this idea is alrdy published in dec'06 then absolutly this is stolen by the student...
fuck off and close the subject....so simple.

rahool
Activity Score 67
Art Director
brandsurgeon's picture

Uh... I won't try to be smart here. I DON'T GET IT.

brandsurgeon
Activity Score 693
Copywriter |

Most times, worst enemies used to be best friends...

rags's picture

i kinda liked it!!

rags
Activity Score 11
ideas@work
Guest's picture

Don't work!!!! I spend 2 minutes triying to understand

Guest
Advertisement
Featured Content

Latest Collections

Advertisement
Advertisement
Campaign Submission
Upload Your Work
Get Featured on AotW
Submit Now