Advertisement
Log in or register to post comments
Hadrons's picture

so? is there any unique position?

Hadrons
Activity Score 6041

THERE'S NO HEAVIER BURDEN THAN A GREAT POTENTIAL

rodrig's picture

Hadrons, are you an account? You rarely understand ideas. This is a very good idea.

rodrig
Activity Score 8
BFB's picture

And You've been a member for 40 min.
I'm guessing it's so you can comment on your own campaign, but I'm just adding one plus one here.
Anyway, I agree with Hadrons. This isn't a great print.

BFB
Activity Score 936
Copywriter
jponino's picture

lmao !!!!
who are you kidding???
first , this ad is .... a total crap ! this is so first idea.... oh, let's tag so i can rehydrate..... i can't even imagine why the client gave his green light to this shit !
and moreover, 8 pencils attacking more than thousands pencils ??? not sure your voice gonna count here ! if you really think this is a super ad, you probably have to change your job

jponino
Activity Score 601
Copywriter at ISCOM, copywriter and art director
skeMaMen's picture

So, if you have thousands pencils, than you're fu**ing' smart...?

skeMaMen
Activity Score 428
Graphic & Prepress designer |

>>> Designed to be signed...

mr.x's picture

this idea is okay. executions is terrible. but your comment is really offensive. where do you come off telling people to change their jobs?! and pencils? thousand pencils doesn't mean shit. it just means that you spend a lot of time on aotw.

mr.x
Activity Score 998
Forsbergs Skola
Quinqui31's picture

yes, it is. the execution if just awfully terrible! and i'm agree with the rest things you said

Quinqui31
Activity Score 57
Graphic Designer at IUTIRLA
Nike Diesel's picture

@RODRIG
+1 on the personal attack.
-1 for rating this ad through the roof.

Nike Diesel
Activity Score 13630
Art Director
Conceptual-eye's picture

How can this be a "very good idea" if its already done. The art's poor, real bad photoshop. I bet this is a scam, since it's really bad produced, look at the background for god sake!

Also, stop commenting your ads, thats lame.

Conceptual-eye
Activity Score 99
Art Director
Hadrons's picture

I take it you are following my posts... I am an analyst. The brains behind a good campaign & strategy. :-)
As for your opinion that this is a good idea - let me laugh. Out loud.

Hadrons
Activity Score 6041

THERE'S NO HEAVIER BURDEN THAN A GREAT POTENTIAL

riyelam's picture

Though Rodrig is wrong you also can't say that an analyst's brain is behind a good campaign and strategy... they just one of many. And you can't rate a AD good or bad unless you the TG, Client, Strategy, etc.

riyelam
Activity Score 366
Graphic Designer at Linc Pen & Plastics Limited
andylefty's picture

I'm a fan.

andylefty
Activity Score 4535
Graphic Designer at Central Saint Martins College of Art and Design
Roger Keynes's picture

Get the Comms strategy... it's the execution that isn't quite there.
Bupa Health Insurance doing a similar 'Find a healthier you' campaign in Australia.

Roger Keynes
Activity Score 5498
Copywriter |

The Jobless Writer
Will Think for Salary

zerocool's picture

Hadrons - I find your strategic mind and quirky cleverness irresistible. IM me for marriage.

zerocool
Activity Score 455
Hadrons's picture

Thanks. I guess.

Hadrons
Activity Score 6041

THERE'S NO HEAVIER BURDEN THAN A GREAT POTENTIAL

hmaffia's picture

Nice idea.

Lame execution.

hmaffia
Activity Score 746
Copywriter at Universidade de Brasila |

http://heliomaffia.com.br

khronos's picture

I like it...it works and they arent trying too hard...kudos

khronos
Activity Score 998
Copywriter
ishiboy's picture

Nope, I think this is a good idea - suits & planners, not withstanding. And yes, the execution could have been better. And definitely, this doesn't seem like a first thought. I also need to point out to a few people here, that it's not fair to be critical just for the sake of it.

ishiboy
Activity Score 497
Creative Director at Mumbai, India
iambusy's picture

its not at all interesting...

iambusy
Activity Score 2219
Copywriter |

busy.

iambusy's picture

lame

iambusy
Activity Score 2219
Copywriter |

busy.

MicheleVirgilio's picture

Not bad but not so special for me.

MicheleVirgilio
Activity Score 2617
sambuca's picture

really really bad photoshop....
no concept at all...

sambuca
Activity Score 1066
Art Director at tolingo GmbH
nepotiums's picture

Firstly, an Idea isn't an idea until it speaks for itself. Out here, I see nothing. If you get offended by all means, correct me. If you can't - stick to my point.

nepotiums
Activity Score 251
Copywriter
joelapompe's picture

done in TV commercial years ago!

joelapompe
Activity Score 3853
Phil Lestino's picture

Just thought I'd comment because I'm falling behind on pencils (and pecils make you clever).....otherwise this ad is brilliant because it's got so many people arguing about how crap it is!

Phil Lestino
Activity Score 1684
Lamadruidt's picture

Besides Gatorade colors...

Lamadruidt
Activity Score 27
Featured Content

Latest Collections

Advertisement