Advertisement

Shoes

Agency Network: 
Published/Aired: 
February 2009
Viking Print Ad -  Shoes

Description

Print advertisement created by Publicis, France for Viking, within the category: Industrial, Agriculture.

Caption

A beautiful lawn deserves respect.

Advertising Agency: Publicis Conseil Paris, France
Creative Directors: Olivier Altmann, Hervé Plumet
Art Directors / Copywriters: Mathieu Degryse, Yves-Eric Deboey
Photographer: Cedric Delsaux
Log in or register to post comments

Highest Rated

bknowlden's picture

Agreed. Should have been sidewalk/lawn combo. Can't believe they would miss something that basic.

bknowlden
Activity Score 3647
Art Director |

--
brandon

www.brandonknowlden.com

monicamexico's picture

But the shoes are on the lawn. Doesn't make sense.

monicamexico
Activity Score 830
bknowlden's picture

Agreed. Should have been sidewalk/lawn combo. Can't believe they would miss something that basic.

bknowlden
Activity Score 3647
Art Director |

--
brandon

www.brandonknowlden.com

Ed Mintone's picture

sigh

Ed Mintone
Activity Score 585
Other
remotedt's picture

i understand your point... but if you want to get that picky, who's to say the dudes who's shoes we see, didn't set there shoes down where we see them. the reason the shoes were removed from there feet is because RUNNING in cleats would ruin the grass... not just the cleats themselves. it's understood that the players removed there shoes before playing there game.

furthermore, if there were concrete next to the field to please you... there'd be someone else complaining that "there wouldn't really be concrete right there, this is bullshit," so... where does the line get drawn?

remotedt
Activity Score 92
graphic designer
CJR785's picture

The playing field would be infront of the shoes. Its almost like when you go into a dojo. You take your shoes off before you get on the mats out of respect. Thats what i get from this, i could be wrong.

CJR785
Activity Score 50
Graphic Designer / Art Director
Nanel's picture

i like this one a lot

Nanel
Activity Score 283
Copywriter
Guest's picture

The criticisms are valid but I like this ad. Let's face we all get it.

Guest
arsenicpants's picture

balls

arsenicpants
Activity Score 12
ORISHAS76's picture

no esta bueno el anuncio, por muchas razones.

ORISHAS76
Activity Score 344
Guest's picture

cuales

Guest
Guest's picture

I got it and liked it when I first saw it.
But the test of a great ad, is that you can't really knock it down.
Nice job analyzing this one commentators.
I agree that if there was cement or blacktop where the shoes are,
it would have been an amazing ad. But it's still good.

I guess what they meant to say is that you would not walk on the main part of the field.
But regardless, this oversight in art direction hurts this idea.

What a damn shame. I still give it an 8 because the idea is there.
2 points off for execution.

Guest
NatalieM's picture

I agree with you. It is definitely a good one, but overlooking that powerful tweak takes away from it as a whole.

NatalieM
Activity Score 1685
Topolewski |

-Natalie
http://www.nataliemarion.com

feebes's picture

yeah this ad doesnt seem to be thought out as long as it should have been, because the shoes are on the lawn anyway. but the idea is clever

feebes
Activity Score 29
home
Guest's picture

baaaad

Guest
luispiter's picture
luispiter
Activity Score 2756
comunication
Guest's picture

very funny, gets your attention, which is the whole point for Vicking...

Guest
Guest's picture

another take could have been famous footballers playing barefoot.

Guest
Guest's picture

I would rather eat your shorts. It’s a bit stupid and pointless, but i really like it somehow.

http://www.stillad.com

 Shoes

Guest
izzlah's picture

hey, goood

izzlah
Activity Score 229
Copywriter
Guest's picture

Shame on you....DDB Paris concept, on DDB Paris client... 5 years ago. You know it guys, don't pretend you didn't.

Guest
Brainsugar's picture

I think a guest from DDB Paris want to say something...

Brainsugar
Activity Score 1631
Copywriter
Guest's picture

Very nice

Guest
Rabubi's picture

It shouldn't be about respect. I should be about the feeling of bare feet on freshly cut grass. Reminds me of childhood. Soccer in the back yard.

Rabubi
Activity Score 560
Copywriter
Guest's picture

Rabubi - you talk about the physical experience, while they attempt more to make it transcendental - less personal, higher prestige. Like mosque or dojo quoted before.

As for me - I think the ad defends itself against criticism pointed out in the first comments. The point about there being a concrete or other artificial surface would be agreed in normal life. But in stadiums it doesn't work that way. As far as I remember, all official regulations treat those 2 sides of grass differently. The shoes are outside the pitch - which is sacred (so the transcendental metaphore works) and has to be of top quality. They are within the field of play, but in the least important/worthy part of it (for training, safe "landing" or throw-ins), not on the pitch itself.

Regulations set in place for Europe specify that each pitch has to have a few meters of grass around it (pitch: 105x76 field of play: 120x80) so they couldn't fit in any sidewalk - it's not allowed. So what is seen as a mistake by individual client may be actually the right thing for a corporate sporting client.

So to conclude - for someone interested only in grass/lawn mainteinance this would be better off with a sidewalk or actually might have gone with a completely different metaphore, like Rabubi said - childhood memories would be great.
But for a big proffessional sporting client it's better the way it is. And I think that's the better way, because sporting pitches are supposed to be and probably are seen publicly as "the best of the best" lawns there are. So Viking caters for the very best pieces of grass there are. Hence, it may as well take on every other pitch.

Guest
Guest's picture

you destroy the grass when you play rugby, not when you walking on.

Guest
ackattak's picture

I like it, despite the logical loophole. It gets the point across nice and quickly.

ackattak
Activity Score 396
Copywriter
Guest's picture

very good

Guest
Advertisement