Comments (15)

Log in or register to post comments
bknowlden's picture
Activity Score 3647

I was under the impression Bailey Lauerman already claimed this ground with their work that was in Archive for the Smithsonian last year...

mikelite's picture
Activity Score 1031

yes, but originality isn't a requirement for most places.

firat's picture
Activity Score 99

I think you are talking about these ads.

Vudu6's picture
Activity Score 81

I can't see your link - its not loading. Anyone got another link? These ads actually reminded me a little of the ogilvy ads with numbers written to look like signatures or something like that... memory fuzzy... long day.

k-rocka's picture
Activity Score 426

These are executed better than the Smithsonian. The signature actually looks illustrative as opposed to just being an extension of the signature.

bknowlden's picture
Activity Score 3647

You arguably have a point, but I can't take a great idea and execute a little better and call it my own great work.

Rog's picture
Activity Score 6080

Despite all the previous goings on...
Cool thought.

>>>> That's not an ad. THIS is an ad.

chinaski's picture
Activity Score 951

this idea was done in an ad competition called "beyin firtınası" (brain storm) in Turkey and Kurcebe Turgul who was in the jury and who is also the president of Medina Turgul DDB, seems to have adopted it.

Desi's picture
Activity Score 1042

I don't think the idea's been copied. First of all the previous ads were never well know enough and secondly how many have we come up with ideas that's been done before.

These ideas are atleast for a real breif. Well done.

chinaski's picture
Activity Score 951

"what's the limit for being 'well known enough' ?", one would ask.
i think it's a matter of self respect and self esteem. not just practicality.

Spanky's picture
Activity Score 4899

archive is pretty well known. i'd say it's a blatant copy.

Punch's picture
Activity Score 612

Todos los creditos se hacen con una firma, luego de haber pasado todas las evaluaciones.

No veo ningun beneficio relevante con este banco. Y la ejecucion grafica es pobre.

"no silencies lo que no sabes expresar".

bompa's picture
Activity Score 318

Me gusta, y que bueno que alguien escriba en español. Bien Punch

RITALIN's picture
Activity Score 91

Sí, pero el beneficio es super directo: firmas y listo. Me gusta la ejecución.
Well done!

Digital Integration Director of McCann Santiago

ALAA's picture
Activity Score 441

I love it... simple and creative.. looks fresh.