Advertisement
Agency Network: 
Published/Aired: 
February 2012

Description

Print advertisement created by Ogilvy, Hong Kong for Beijing Sports Radio, within the category: Media.

Advertising Agency: Ogilvy & Mather, Hong Kong
Executive Creative Directors: Simon Handford, Sandy Chan
Creative Director: Alvin Lim
Art Directors: Alvin Lim, Sonny Tjahjadi, Jason Pan, Hubert Yeung
Associate CD / Copywriter: Richard Sorensen
Retoucher: A Thousand Eyes
Account team: Tak Chi Lee, Paul Lam, Cao Yu
Log in or register to post comments
KimKong's picture

Now THIS is how you use a dialogue bubble! Kudos!

KimKong
Activity Score 198
Hadrons's picture

Edit response:

Mkaytie link & comment is valid.

http://www.academyart.edu/spring_show_2011/images/lg/ADV/019.jpg It's a 'rip off' idea !

Hadrons
Activity Score 6041

THERE'S NO HEAVIER BURDEN THAN A GREAT POTENTIAL

MK-tessa's picture

I really hope that this was a simple mistake. An Academy of Art student did this one last year in 2011. I noticed this was published 2012. Either way great way to use a talk bubble. http://www.academyart.edu/spring_show_2011/images/lg/ADV/019.jpg

MK-tessa
Activity Score 216
Art Director at student
kr34t1v3's picture

oops just saw your link could this be the same student or a copy cat? I removed my ratings for the safe side.

kr34t1v3
Activity Score 33
Creative Director
kr34t1v3's picture

would not be completed unless someone place two portable toilets on both far ends. Well it really make sense here as the image has been created using so many tid bits.
great graphic design skills.
idea seems to be s stolen one.

kr34t1v3
Activity Score 33
Creative Director
MicheleVirgilio's picture

nice

MicheleVirgilio
Activity Score 2617
saya's picture

ALready done:-(

saya
Activity Score 353
Art Director at McCann Worldgroup, Bengaluru
Bacon Face's picture

Enough with the "done" and "rip-off" comments.
Interesting to still see you around Hadrons, after all that hooha.

Bacon Face
Activity Score 107
Manoma's picture

Good idea, and good realisation ;-)
(clap clap!)

Manoma
Activity Score 1108
Copywriter
thedesignaddict's picture
thedesignaddict
Activity Score 5403
Art Director at Freelance
celini's picture

Una buena idea. Clara, sencilla y con una excelente realización.

celini
Activity Score 90
albinojc's picture

Ogilvy. Always recreating ideas around the world.

albinojc
Activity Score 285
Art Director at AMP Propaganda |

cargocollective.com/albinojc

Panda Man's picture

Really clever way to using speaking bubble

Panda Man
Activity Score 15
Billoughsby's picture

Will quietly say: In an era when millions globally* are tasked with cranking ad material 40 hrs a week, the odds of a wholly unintentional overlap in concepts occurring continue to improve and are probably slightly greater than the odds that you will die of cancer (1 in 4), much greater than your odds of dying in an auto accident (1 in 100)†.

• approximately 1,473,631 people in America alone are employed full or part time in advertising careers, according to online sources

†again, in America

The fact that there are very few geniuses in the tribe we are descended from will mean we often arrive at the same "epiphany" at the same moment. Someone needs to do a study of this phenom (with really cool infographics so ad people will read it, of course).

Billoughsby
Activity Score 5150
Art Director |

That's it.

Spanky's picture

When the agency in question is based in China, the odds of thievery go up dramatically. Roughly the same odds that you will die one day.

Spanky
Activity Score 4899
Other
Billoughsby's picture

Or maybe you're thinking about tennis shoes.

Billoughsby
Activity Score 5150
Art Director |

That's it.

mr.x's picture

I get what you are saying. I mean, it's like music. Music producers produce new songs and beats everyday. And a couple of them is going to remind you of another song. Not because they are copying other songs. But because there are limited number of chords, and melodies will eventually repeat itself. But the same doesn't go with this Ad. For me it's not like a melody is repeating itself, it's more like they stole a hole verse and chorus from a song and made a new hit.

mr.x
Activity Score 998
Forsbergs Skola
CommandZ's picture

Well put Bill'O. Theoretically all ideas are out there floating about in the ether. The odds seem to favor more than one creative pulling that idea down or having that same "Ah ha" moment based on the same idea epiphany. First to market wins, the second poor sap will always get the "done" comment.

CommandZ
Activity Score 2509
Creative Director
Billoughsby's picture

Thanks, man. This can be a lonely place.

Billoughsby
Activity Score 5150
Art Director |

That's it.

Hadrons's picture

@ Billoughsby

I have problem with your theory - can you explain the following;

http://dvserver.net/addy2011/pages/page108.html - was published at June 8th, 2011
according to Ivan this ad was published Feb. 2012.

If it was about 2 weeks apart, between publications - I might see your point, and with a grain of salt regarding these geniuses... but now ..

Unless you want to raise a philosophical question as to why we are judging so severely the notion of copying/duplicating in advertising,
However, when it come to another creative form like fashion, architecture and movies for example, we are considerably more forgiving...

Hadrons
Activity Score 6041

THERE'S NO HEAVIER BURDEN THAN A GREAT POTENTIAL

Hadrons's picture

You know what, I see no point bringing this topic here.
Very few people can have a decent well informed educated conversation, here.

Hadrons
Activity Score 6041

THERE'S NO HEAVIER BURDEN THAN A GREAT POTENTIAL

Billoughsby's picture

If the thing is stolen, shame on them. That goes without saying. I was interested in a broader inquiry, one maybe, but not necessarily, pinned to this specific set of ads. No theory -- just an acknowledgment of how these things probably do go down sometimes.

I agree with your last sentence to this extent; Nothing energizes people like "Done", which is a species of "Gotcha!", which I consider one of the problems with the internet, media and discourse in general. I'd probably rather not discuss it either because the last time I got into one of these things here, it turned into a joke.

Billoughsby
Activity Score 5150
Art Director |

That's it.

mr.x's picture

Hadrons, your educated and extraordinarily intellectual comments gives me a hard-on. Lmfao, I love these self claimed geniuses.

mr.x
Activity Score 998
Forsbergs Skola
Hadrons's picture

"Belching (also known as burping, ructus, or eructation) involves the release of gas from the digestive tract (mainly esophagus and stomach) through the mouth. It is usually accompanied with a typical sound and, at times, an odor."

Take some alka-seltzer.

Hadrons
Activity Score 6041

THERE'S NO HEAVIER BURDEN THAN A GREAT POTENTIAL

mr.x's picture

Another genius comment!

mr.x
Activity Score 998
Forsbergs Skola
Billoughsby's picture

I appreciate the effort you expended to at least get what I'm saying, Mr. X. I would question Ogilvy very closely about the, er, provenence of this concept and campaign. I don't take thievery lightly. Among other things, though, I question the chances of every high level creative out there having seen this student work. Just posing the thought/question.

Billoughsby
Activity Score 5150
Art Director |

That's it.

mr.x's picture

It doesn't feel like an obvious concept and that is why I don't think the creatives from Ogilvy came up with this idea. It's not a coincidence, it's pure theft. And it happens all the time.

mr.x
Activity Score 998
Forsbergs Skola
Billoughsby's picture

Well there you go. From "I get what you're saying" to absolutist mode "it's pure theft."

Not touching this again. No offense. See ya guys.

Billoughsby
Activity Score 5150
Art Director |

That's it.

mr.x's picture

Non taken. But I thought it was clear when I said "it's more like they stole a hole verse and chorus from a song and made a new hit.", by that I meant that the Ogilvy guys most likely got a little too inspired by the first original ad.

mr.x
Activity Score 998
Forsbergs Skola
Billoughsby's picture

It's all good Mr. X. It may well be stolen. Just trying to practice "slow to judge".

Billoughsby
Activity Score 5150
Art Director |

That's it.

Mr.Abc's picture

Very good. No reason to be ashamed of.
The world is big. The internet is fast.
You can´t know every f** student work in the world.

I like.

Mr.Abc
Activity Score 50
vote4pedro's picture

Best of Show in the national ADDY awards isn't exactly obscure.

vote4pedro
Activity Score 4601
Copywriter
pedro.martoli's picture

Simple, intelligent and efficient. Good ad!

pedro.martoli
Activity Score 34
Art Director at Miami Ad School São Paulo / Brasil
joelapompe's picture
joelapompe
Activity Score 3861
Michaelsmagic's picture

simple and clever and i like the messagebox~

Michaelsmagic
Activity Score 261
MattSpencer's picture

This concept definitely would make a great visual impact, especially in print when blown up to bigger sizes. I love the use of the speech bubble, it is subtle yet stands out and grabs your attention.

MattSpencer
Activity Score 23
Advertisement